I have been reading this thread with interest. Fair play Jonathon you are good at starting interesting threads.
I think anyone who doesn't see the down side of the high property prices in the UK is being a little naive. A lot of people have benefited from the high price of property and land....mainly land owners and anyone who owns more than one house especially. And of course anyone who inherits a house or a share of. The majority of people in the UK have done very nicely out of this bubble. I may do one day when my parents/in-laws pop their clogs.
But you have to feel for anyone trying to get their foot on the property ladder. That is really what Big J is talking about. OK he is wanting to do it slightly differently from most, but before the last 20 years of crazy property value increases it would have been probably quite feasible for him to do exactly what he is suggesting. For an average decent family home in Devon to be worth maybe £350,000 when Devon is full of people in the tourist industry earning maybe £17,000 per year is a huge problem. The system is broken. Same problem in London and most of South East England. Many people can only ever rent (at a rate that means they will never be able to save up a deposit) or hope they will one day inherit.
It is a very sad situation, not for the majority who are doing very nicely thank you, but for the millions who may never be able to get on the property ladder, and are stuck in a cycle of ever-increasing rent.
I for one think that if Brexit means the property market crashes, or at least drops 20% or so this could be very welcome relief for a lot of people.
I also want to just say that it is so ironic that as this thread highlights, the only type of activity that is fully supported and for which an AOC is likely to be granted is exactly the sort of activity that is contributing vastly to global warming and food insecurity. Sustainable profitable forestry is not allowed, yet unsustainable animal agriculture is encouraged and heavily subsidised. And when I say unsustainable animal agriculture, I am not suggesting all animal husbandry is unsustainable, but if you take a look at the bigger picture such farming is most certainly unsustainable.