Thanks for the replies
D22 has a well documented engine problem, that to their shame Nissan tried to avoid, deny and denounce - thanks to the chaps at knackered Navara they eventually had to admit to the fault and start to put it right. But NOT before it cost many people alot of money, work, their job, etc. Perhaps a bit old hat.
Similiarly Land Rover denied the head gasket fault on the K series petrol engine as fitted to the Freelander. As I know to my cost and disgust.
So the older Navara's out
NP300 is a bit old, but hopefully the no more reliability problems
D40 Navara, unfortunately has some problems , but none that compare with the D22 Navara. However, I don't like all the electrics and the lack of a proper lower box controlled by a gearstick, rather than a button. Perhaps a bit too lifestyle. Not sure how it would cope in N. Africa, which is somewhere I quite fancy visiting with whatever truck I end up with - if I do end up with a 4x4.
L200, old shape, just too old for my liking.
L200, current shape, like the single cab, but really don't like th elook of the club or double cab. There are some comments around about various reliability problems or faults, but none that stands out that would stop me buying.
Hilux - old shape, another truck with a great reliability record, but rather underpowered and not the best tow tug. Plus hideously overpriced for such an old vehicle.
New shape Hiluxs, good reliability reputation, one friend has driven his 4 times to West Africa full loaded with no problems. However, they have a very poor recommended tow weight rating at 2250kg, although they are plated at 2800kg, and several reports of them towing that sort of weight without a problem - although I do wonder if thaty s the owners talking 'up' his truck.
LR130/110, superb off road ability, against Iron age design and ride, but the only truck witht he benefit of permanent 4wd. Well aware of their ability, as I took a 130 overland to Cape Town. Very expensive but hold their price well - apparently. This is probably the case, until I buy one then they will become the only truck that nobody wants!
Why, oh why, don't LR make a Disco dropside/utility/pick up, etc.
Never really fancied an Isuzu, was told they were a bit behind the field in design and ride quality.
Ford Ranger/Mazda, old shape performs well as a work truck by reputation but on a very old and underpowered engine.
Ranger/Mazda current shapes - seem to have become very popular, but is that down to price alone? Lots of comments that they struggle to tow anything like their plated load.
Land Cruiser 40 series is ancient but almost unstoppable.
60 is a station wagon only
78/79 series have an awesome reputation for longevity, I know someone who owned one with in excess of 500, 000 miles in Africa and despite looking like scrap was still going stong. And the ability of the straight six is just legendary. I have driven quite a few of them and really like them if only they were available over here. But think they would have forced LR hand years ago.
The heart says LR but the head says a Toyota, however perhaps pricewise an L200 or Ranger???
Still in a damn quandary!