Its great to have an "official" on here to discuss this with, long overdue and very welcomed, long may it continue and definatley no apologies needed for over contributing to threads!
I personaly feel that wether we agree or dissagree with what the arb association is doing or not doing for "us" is taking a shallow view of the value gained from any grade of membership to the AA, be that AAAC or just being a registered paying member/associate.
The fact is with membership of the AA (any grade) you are contributing to the cause and connecting to a force that represents arboriculture in the U.K
The more of us "financialy involved" the greater the force.
Is it really a question of wether we can afford to be members, or one of wether we can afford NOT to be?
I couldnt pay my subs last year, and havent renewed yet but when i do I will pay two years worth because wether I agree or dissagree with what is or is not being done i know my contribution and membership helps progress and that is all I want from the AA.
I would like to see a more unified arboricultural body, one that as Tony Sorensen suggested (a shared view?), incorporates ALL interested parties by joining the woodland trust, the forestry commision and the AA we would see a force to be recconed with, a mighty force capable of great things and representing a very large, tree interested party. Representing ALL tree realated interests, from the public who enjoy walks in the ancient woods to researchers looking to fund a project.
It is true that AAAC status does NOT garauntee a quality job, and that does need changing, how i dont know, if you took poor work as a bench mark for removal some of the biggest names/financial inputs would be lost! Random spot checks? been working for AA aproved firms for 10 years, NEVER have I been subjected to a random check by the AA, you need to stop claiming them or activley carry them out, its a threat only if it happens!
On the other hand if random checks where a real threat how many would remain AAAC for very long?
The AA have a tough job, and I respect what it is they are trying to do, it has to be the toughest role and we should all be supporting that role in anyway we can. pay your subs pay your dues, the AA represent us all for better or worse and its a job you or I couldnt do any better!