My point is Kev, the AA have said nothing that I have heard in the defence of rope access methods in tree work, they have produced a guide to working with MEWPs but have not told us when we can or should use one. At best they are sitting on the fence on this issue, at worst they are undermining the injdustry they supposedly represent. I want to know if i am breaking H+S law by not using a MEWP where it would be possible to do so? If I am then the AA has totaly failed in its duty to this industry.
The AA is drifting further and further away from the average contractor and only representing and supporting a vocal minority of generaly larger contractors who target a "high end" customer who will pay a premium for their services. Look in any yellow pages, the majority of the contractors advertising will not be AAAC, they will be everything from complete cowboys to quality firms who work to the same exacting standards as the AAACs but who haven't signed up for the self congratulatory pat on the back of joining the scheme.
A GOOD scheme would be inclusive NOT exclusive ie bring the less well trained less well run companies on board and help them to improve, not set the bar so high that many in the industry see the AAAC scheme as totaly un attainable. If necessary keep the sceme as it is and introduce an entry level scheme for the aspiring smaller firms. This is not sour grapes on my part, I nearly became AAAC 2 Years ago but decided that it would do little to help my business prosper as it is so poorly advertised, like many others on this forum I am confident that my professional standards are every bit as good as any one operating within the scheme, I just feel why pay for a pat on the back that will do nothing for my profits?
I can't imagine there is another industry in Britain where the trade organisation has such a poor reputation within its industry. There are plenty of companys out there whose standards are well below what our industry should expect and dare I say it some on this forum too. This is no reason to bury your head in the sand and pretend they don't exist, help them improve, and if they won't improve give your sceme some clout and publicity and shame them into shaping up and joining in. When every other customer asks "are you AAAC?" people like me will start taking an interest, untill then I'm alright Jack.