I have wondered about this issue for years, and my opinion has changed totally, I used to believe that we needed a strong voice in the industry to help standardise the skills and qualifications required by all tree contractors. I also thought that having a strong lobby group would help improve the legislation that we are expected to comply with day to day.
I now believe that we would be better off if the organisations who purport to represent our industry were weaker than they currently are, It is not the ethos of these bodies that is wrong, more the fact that so many of their members seem to be either from a non contracting background or disgruntled former contractors who want to make life as difficult as possible for the smaller firms who perhaps they see as unfair competition because they spend their time working instead of attending seminars on soils and the latest H&S regs.
I consider myself to be a "good arborist", I have done the AATech and PTI as well as numerous NPTC's but I no longer believe that we should all be forcing every one else to do the same in the belief that it would make them easier to compete with. It won't, there will always be guys doing tree work on the cheap. End of. Just as there will always be guys selling cheap logs. Its far better to worry about where you and your business are going than keep looking over your shoulder at everyone else.
There is a very high proportion of trainers involved at a high level in the AA etc, they will be present in disproportionate numbers at AA events and seminars, their influence on AA thinking is not necessarily in the interests of the average contractor, more NPTC's, pointless refresher courses, constantly changing NPTC definitions and qualifications etc. We need this like a hole in the head, because those of us who do commercial as well as domestic work will eventually find that as LA and commercial clients keep asking for more and more qualifications and we keep spending money putting our staff through them, there will come a time when we are so expensive that we will no longer be able to do any domestic work. Many others have reached the same conclusion and decided the the answer is to make everyone do all the tests to create a level playing field, hence my points above, however as the domestic tree market is totally unregulated there will always be those who won't bother. And therefore this utopian dream where we all have hundreds of letters after our names and no one gets to work on a 10 foot leylandii without producing a 2"file of paperwork for the little old lady who owns it is exactly that, a dream, and it always will be.
Far better to keep things as they are, there will be those like me who have invested heavily in training and those who haven't and as things stand just now I am able to compete in all sectors of the market, I like being able to do that, and I fear that a stronger trade body would force me to choose between a low cost, low level of training domestic market ethos and a high cost, high level of training commercial market.
The only way I would support an stronger trade body or association is if ONLY contractors could join. No trainers allowed (by order of the management)