Felling Large Holm Oak

[Mr Ed]

On watching the Video again, i have decided -

The hedge is comprehensively dead. No way is it recovering from that.

 

That felling like that was bad workmanship, and a bad call. I could have dismantled it in under an hour without smashing the hedge.

 

Tana, this is not a go at you, I assume it was not your call, you were there to place shackles.

[Ross Smith]

On watching the Video again, i have decided -

The hedge is comprehensively dead. No way is it recovering from that.

 

That felling like that was bad workmanship, and a bad call. I could have dismantled it in under an hour without smashing the hedge. i consider myself a quick climber when needed mr ed and if you had seen what was involved in dismantling that tree it would have been a long tough day probably day and a half and to see someone do it in a hour would of been insane,as for bad workmanship i think thats abit strong.its simple,the job was to fell and do it it safely,which is exactly what happened.as people have said before we all have to make calls and calls have to be made and its a tough industry to keep all these experinced and expert brains happy.i posted this thread to get the response i got and learn from it and i have but stand by my call.

 

Tana, this is not a go at you, I assume it was not your call, you were there to place shackles.

 

i consider myself a quick climber when needed mr ed and if you had seen what was involved in dismantling that tree it would have been a long tough day probably day and a half and to see someone do it in a hour would of been insane,as for bad workmanship i think thats abit strong.its simple,the job was to fell and do it it safely,which is exactly what happened.as people have said before we all have to make calls and calls have to be made and its a tough industry to keep all these experinced and expert brains happy.i posted this thread to get the response i got and learn from it and i have but stand by my call.

[Mike Hill]

 

 

Gay cowboy,sayes Good Work!

[Big dog]

Tana, just to clarify something for me, was that tree in immediate danger of uprooting/collapse?

[Ross Smith]

Tana, just to clarify something for me, was that tree in immediate danger of uprooting/collapse?

potentially yes.it was a big tree in a vunerable position to "wait a while and see what happens"

[Tommy_B]

 

 

Gay cowboy,sayes Good Work!

 

Ha ha!! I nearly fouled myself laughing!!! If the gay cowboy says its a good job......

[Mike Hill]

quote=Tommy_B;50076]Ha ha!! I nearly fouled myself laughing!!! If the gay cowboy says its a good job......

 

Gay Cowboy knows its a good job,close the thread or you'll all be draggin brush for him in your Y fronts

[Tommy_B]

quote=Tommy_B;50076]Ha ha!! I nearly fouled myself laughing!!! If the gay cowboy says its a good job......

 

Gay Cowboy knows its a good job,close the thread or you'll all be draggin brush for him in your Y fronts

 

CLOSE THE THREAD CLOSE THE THREAD CLOSE THE THREAD!!!

[Mr Ed]

Why is there a desire for the thread to be closed?

[Tommy_B]

Its more a desire to not see any more of that cowboy!!!