Finding the right person for advice

[Haironyourchest]

It's safer not to ask too many questions.

[Mark J]

On 28/08/2021 at 15:07, Jiat2 said:

Have a problem with a neighbouring tree.

 

For reasons at present I am unable to discuss this with them at all.

 

That does not mean I can just leave things as the tree is huge and I have a concern.

 

I have looked and looked at online searches but it seems I am unable to find what I am looking for.

 

I want a qualified expert opinion as to if a tree is safe as a number of things have happened.

 

Along with a number of worrying signs around the tree base.

 

I would want rather to get an expert opinion than show photos etc.

 

The tree is huge and concern over the stability etc following works and the general condition.

 

I only seem able to find tree surgeons who have qualifications but nothing extensive.

 

Where do you go to find who would be considered an expert who could do a survey and know whether the tree is at risk or not?

 

What qualification should I look for?

 

I assume that a general tree surgeon may well have many years experience and excellent in their field. However would appreciate an expert report.

 

Any help would be much appreciated.

Ideally you want someone who is NQF level 5+, has a PTI qualification, and appropriate PI insurance,  professional membership of AA, ISA or ICF would also stand them in good stead.
The biggest foreseeable issue is the lack of access to observe all aspects of the tree.  I wouldn't write a report on a tree I couldn't see fully.
Take up the offer on this thread, at least then you know where you stand.

PM me if you get stuck, I'm heading to Kent next week and will be stopping off in Melton Mowbray on the way down, 

Good luck.

Edited August 30, 2021 by Mark J

[kevinjohnsonmbe]

2 hours ago, Khriss said:

Is It Safe... 

 

Brilliant!

 

Never seen the film - don’t want to if he’s about to have dental ‘treatment’ - but, a fine choice of film clip to summarise the post 😂

[Khriss]

8 hours ago, kevinjohnsonmbe said:

Brilliant!

 

Never seen the film - don’t want to if he’s about to have dental ‘treatment’ - but, a fine choice of film clip to summarise the post 😂

Just got my dental appointment through , so it been weighing on my mind , Kev  . K

Edited August 31, 2021 by Khriss
( brilliant film abt Nazi diamond smuggler - Lawrence Olivier )

[daltontrees]

Sometimes I am quite embarrased at the treatment members of the public get when coming onto this site for help. If you're the type of memeber who thinks it's going to be too difficult a job, if you're the type who will criticise a would-be client for not understanding the ins and outs of tree law and risk assessment, for not knowing what you know, well fair enough the poster is better off without you, and probably better off without the cynicism and speculation.

 

At least Mark J has had a go at a helpful answer, although I'd add to his comments that a report that states that it is not possible to reach a definitive conclusion (because you can't see the tree fully) can be relevant and useful in the right context.

 

I have had first-hand experiences of supposed survey reports which are shockingly incompetent, by people who are way out of their depth. Sorry to have to be blunt but they have mostly been from contractors playing at consultancy. And a few from 'consultants' who really ought to go back to school or back up their tree experience with some structured learning.

 

So fair enough to the OP for asking for help. He is clearly worried about a tree and needs help from someone who knows their stuff. What's wrong with that? He will be better off with someone with the right helpful attitude who's not seeing it as a difficult client. If I was in the area I'd help but I am 300 miles away. Honestly, some of you have been not just unhelpful but quite rude. 

 

It's bloody obvious what needs to be done for this would-be client. I hope he finds someone with the right credentials and almost cas importantly the right attitude. He can message me for a preliminary opinion of he wants.

[Steve Bullman]

1 hour ago, daltontrees said:

I have had first-hand experiences of supposed survey reports which are shockingly incompetent, by people who are way out of their depth. Sorry to have to be blunt but they have mostly been from contractors playing at consultancy.

How did you get your hands on my reports?