I'm a feller not a climber so can't comment on this, but have questioned climbers a number of times 'I could fell this tree through that gap, why are you climbing it'
Never witnessed a bad accident fortunately
Gravity is an amazing thing, if you cut at the bottom it'll always come down.
Sure some climbers just think everything has to be climbed. Interesting what has been pointed out, the first thing with WAH is do you need to be WAH?
Poor lad, hope he recovers and finds himself a new or slightly different career.