This certainly is a job you learn by doing, but in 'doing' it are we not in an evironment with experienced people showing us the way?
That would be a form of training and I would agree that this is a perfectly acceptable method of learning a skill or trade, it's how I have done it afterall so I can't say too much.
However, there are many people starting out who don't have that facility so need to have formal training.
And then there must come a point where if you're fresh in where no one knows you and you want to be responsible for performing a task, then you need to be able to prove competency.
Which comes back to tickets.
I don't have any climbing or aerial tickets, but I still posess the skills to safely complete some tasks. I also have enough experience and have had some formal training and testing to be able to identify where work falls outside my skillset.
But so many people lack that basic ability.
Knowing what you can't do is as important as knowing what you can do in my book.
So, that ramble leads me back to the original question.
I have just bought a top handled saw off eBay. I don't have tickets specific to its use.
However I have plenty of experience of a top handled saw, having previously had an MS200T which I bought from a proper Stihl dealer, they didn't ask for tickets.
It's just like everything else. If you have enough money you can get whatever you want.
Look at footballers, who can barely tie their laces or spell their name, splashing out on cars far too fast for them which they then crash while hungover.
If you can only buy a top handled saw with a ticket, then all training providers will have to possess a stock of top handled saws to allow us to train in that ticket to allow us to buy and use one.
Then training gets even more prohibitively expensive in these lean times, thefts increase, the black market takes over, things get worse rather than better.
We all know that we are responsible for our own actions, if we buy something which we don't know how to use, it's our own bloody fault when it bites us.
Common sense must be allowed to prevail.
Idiots will always find a way to do things they shouldn't, no rules or regs will really stop them.
Honestly, it's just netting the gene pool, skimming off the rubbish...
Quite often the status quo is just fine, I think this is a case in point.
But please don't play them when I'm around...
Simon