Jump to content


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

About Gnarlyoak

  • Rank
    Senior Member, Raffle sponsor 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014

Personal Information

  • Location:
  • Occupation
    Freelance climber
  • Post code
    SK15 2AU
  • City

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. No if or buts about protected or pest species under the relevant 1981 law ALL nests & brooding birds are protected. Period. About 12 years ago I was ordered out of an oak tree I was dead wooding by an RSPCA officer because there was a crows nest in the tree, and we had been reported as disturbing a live nesting site by a neighbour. This week, with all the fine weather & gardens full of witnesses (potentially many prying eyes) I've only reduced 5 syccy's out of a group of 6 because the 6th tree had an active magpie's nest in the top of the crown. Tenant wasn't too happy (they'd been waiting 18 months for H.A. to pull their finger out), but understood the situation. Bitter sweet irony that in the next few weeks the baby magpie's will probably be dining on baby blue tits; robins and numerous other songbirds. But we still did 5 out of 6 trees, not every tree or hedge for that matter has a nest in this time of year and most old nests are fairly obvious and rarely reused by most bird species, even nesting boxes should be emptied between broods to encourage birds to reuse them. So if there is a nest, there is always another tree job without you can fall back on. The tree/hedge will still be there in a few weeks after the birds have fledged and jogged on. But, when it comes to wood pigeons nesting in conifers for 10months of the year (Feb-Nov) well I'd leave that to each individual's personal conscience!!! Bloody nuisance they are. Shitty varmints!
  2. Wind blown trees with root plate attached have the potential to make your wife a widow in a heartbeat if you attempt to do it yourself without the right tools; knowledge; experience! If you absolutely must have & not be able walk away from a section of that tree; then you have to decide what you are prepared to offer, either in pounds or something else of a bartering value, to get someone in to cut it for you. Seriously man, you could potentially be "smoking in the powder room" if you don't know what you are doing. And if it goes boom you'd be the last to know about it until you're looking down from the heavens on your wife sobbing at your graveside as they lower your coffin in the hole!! Or at the side of your hospital bed wondering what the hell she's supposed to do with a man cabbage in a wheel chair. Is there nobody that you know who has bigger gear and a bit more idea to help you get the section you want/need? Tread carefully and stay safe mate.
  3. Madam, You have most definitely not had your tree reduced by an educated & experienced Arborist. Nor have you had your tree expertly reduced by a skilled & experienced tree surgeon. You do appear to have had your wee taken & bank account pilfered by a butcherer of trees who has left you with an arboricultural embarrassment in your garden. Whatever BS sweet nothings your "arborist" chappy might have whispered in your ear, You might have thought you were talking to Clint Eastwood "Blondie"; you were actually being hood winked by Lee Van Cleef "Angel Eyes"; who in the end gave you an Eli Wallach "Tuco". In other words, in cowboy parlance you thought you were talking to The Good; you were actually talking to The Bad & he most definitely gave you The Ugly! By which time you are sadly hundred's of pounds poorer and even more unhappy with your tree than before. When it comes to tree work, most unenlightened householders a) don't bother getting more than 1 or 2 quotes, b) then go for the cheapest quote anyway. Sometimes it works out OK, other times less so with differing poorer outcomes when compared to expectations &/or potentially ending up at the further end of the scale with the kind of monstrosity you have shown us in your pictures. At this stage you have 3 possible courses of action. 1) Suck it up & live with your mistake and then have it re-pruned by a more reputable & capable tree surgery company in about 5 years time. 2) Get another, but this time reputable tree surgery company in now to fell the remaining monstrosity you have been left with, grind out the stump and replant with a new tree that you can have the pleasure to watch grow during your remaining years at that property. 3) Use your social media accounts & word of mouth to warn all your family, friends and associates not to use the same tree surgery company you did that left you with the back street abortion of a tree you've posted in your pictures. Name & shame dear lady, name & shame to everyone you know, because people who produce that kind of work and take cold hard cash from the unsuspecting public for it should get their comeuppance somewhere. Please note, option 3 can also be used in conjunction with options 1 and 2. But the answer to your original question is NO that is a not an example of a tree reduction that has been done well. Irrespective of species, it matters not whether it is a sycamore or any other, it is the very antithesis of a tree reduction done well! It is certainly a tree that has been reduced, but to sum it up in one word. Appallingly.
  4. Well if you are going to become a European advisor for Echo can you please advise them to make sure they have plenty of spares in stock, in country for their saws please, and available everywhere!! There are a million & 1 outlets all over the web for parts, and bits & bobs for Stihl & Husky saws but a veritable desert for commensurate Echo parts!!! I don't know what it's like for ground saws (I don't own one) but trying to get spares for their top handle saws (I have a CS-360 TES) is a chuffin nightmare. There have been other threads here on AT about the challenges of finding spares for the 2511T so I'm sure it's not an isolated issue for me & my 360. So my advise to Echo would be to buy/rent a big (or bigger) warehouse in the middle of the UK, stock half of it with products you want to sell to the professional user, stock the other half with the spares needed to repair those products when they break. A broken saw or other tool collecting dust on a bench in a workshop whilst trying to source spare parts or waiting for them to be shipped in from the far east or some other far flung global manufacturing point is not going to help the professional user make any money. So if buying an Echo professional work tool means having to endure prolonged down time & wasting more time trying to find spares parts, then I'd be better off spending my hard earned on a Stihl or Husky tool where spares are more readily available and easier to acquire from multiple sources. Otherwise, IMHO, Echo cannot really hope to be a long term viable contender in the UK chainsaw market, and risk just being seen as a small, novel bit part player on the side. As an example, off the shelf parts (when compared to parts I can find for Stihl/Husky) that I am struggling to find (even including on Echo UK's own website) are things like replacement bar; chain sprocket; chain brake spring and or fuel/oil caps. Whilst some official Echo dealerships might have the odd item listed on their own individual websites, I am struck by the prevalence that what few parts are available the majority are listed as "out of stock". Whether this is down to delays along the manufacturing and distribution chain due to Covid or the complex uncertainties brought about by the transition of the UK's departure from the EU's customs union in the run up to Brexit is never clear but "out of stock" smacks of a lack of preparedness and foresight when it comes to Echo's attitude to it's UK after sales market! Whatever new products that Echo might currently have in development to be brought to the marketplace in 2021, if they haven't got an adequate and readily available stock of spare parts to replace bits when they break, then all they are producing is bigger more expensive paper weight to sit on the repairs shelf collecting dust waiting for spares to be sourced from "gawd knows where, gawd knows when"! Just my "two penneth" worth. Thanks.
  5. Cheers Swins, good to know mate. And no, you "REALLY REALLEY" didn't sell me on the TM yet. But I know there must be something good about them as they are always getting recommended but they are also a bit "marmite". 😉 All the best mate.
  6. Spot on mate. I've got slightly compressed L3 & L4 vertebrae in my lower back and the big wide back support on my Kolibri is a godsend. Many moons ago when I climbed in a Komet Butterfly it was torture. So a big back pad is a must really.
  7. Totally agree with all the points you have made. I'd hate to make a costly error, but It's just really not feasible at the moment to travel about the country on a try before you buy scouting mission. Couldn't try a jumper on for size in Next the other week before buying it due to Covid, can see how it might also be a problem bouncing around in half a dozen harnesses in an arb store! And yeah, my gut tells me Skylotech. Always found the Kolibri comfy as, but the new design of the Ignite is a bit of a departure from that. So hence my post to try and get some real world feedback to help shape my perspective.
  8. Not really Carlos. Haven't really got any arb suppliers in my neck of the woods. Closest would be Liverpool, which isn't really that far, but I'm in a Tier 4 Covid area so restrictions on unnecessary travel apply. The other complication is that the retailer in Liverpool only has 1 of my choices in stock, and the other 2 choices they don't stock at all. You are right of course, try before you buy would be preferable but time, distance & pandemics seem to be making life a tad tricky mate.
  9. Aye, you're probably right Lux. I normally like to get my money's worth out of my gear, but it seems these days everything is designed & manufactured to have a limited lifespan, set to self destruct after about a year or just after the warranty runs out forcing you to buy a new replacement!!
  10. Another big up for the Stihl can. 👍🏻 If you think you can save money by buying a Husky can, you will regret it before before summer has come & gone. Anyone thinking of buying one should just set fire to their hard earned cash, then save up & buy a Stihl combi can. Oregon cans are ok, though you might still be better off buying Stihl auto filler spouts (if that's what you're after) for longevity & reliability. If Husky made their saws like they make their cans, it would at least end the ceaseless Stihl saws V Husky saws debate at a stroke.
  11. Which Arbortec model do you go for out of interest.
  12. I had noticed "thumbs up" recommendations for ArbPro Andrew boots in other boot threads on this site. Do they remain consistently good comparable to other popular brands? Anybody else gone for Andrew's without regret or anyone got any negative feedback about them? I do take on board & concur with what others have said about the lack of consistency in the build quality of same model of boots over time. Usually stick with Haix myself, but my current pair have barely lasted 12 months, last pair 18, when previous pairs I've had over half a decade ago lasted over 2 years!
  13. Yes. Thanks spuddog. Usually have to wear two pairs of sock with my current Haix boots, so narrower fit not an issue. Cheers mate, thanks for asking. Edit: though obvs "airstream not the Rock" hence reason for query. Is there a difference & is it worth it?
  14. Nice one. Furrymuff Chris, just the kind of heads up I wanted. Thanks mate ATB for 2021. Take care, be good fella 👍🏻
  15. As a climber: Echo CS2511 10" bar (Small pruning above silky) Stihl MS201 12" bar (Larger pruning; small take downs) Stihl MS200 14" bar (Big pruning; larger take downs) Would rather give up CS2511/MS201 & at least 1 bollock and a garage before my MS200T As a tree surgeon, my ideal garage party would be: Stihl MS200T (12" & 14" bar) Husky 550XP (15" & 18 " bar) Stihl MS441 (20" & 25" bar) Although again 550/441; the garage & both bollocks would be sacrificed before the MS200T. Nuff said! Now jog on son.... nuffin to see hear.... sniff sniff! If I could have only 1 saw with no garage & no bollocks it would be a Stihl MS200T


Arbtalk.co.uk is a hub for the arboriculture industry in the UK.  
If you're just starting out and you need business, equipment, tech or training support you're in the right place.  If you've done it, made it, got a van load of oily t-shirts and have decided to give something back by sharing your knowledge or wisdom,  then you're welcome too.
If you would like to contribute to making this industry more effective and safe then welcome.
Just like a living tree, it'll always be a work in progress.
Please have a look around, sign up, share and contribute the best you have.

See you inside.

The Arbtalk Team

Follow us

  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.