Bleeding canker cure

[David Humphries]

I couldn't be more sceptical about this. It has all the hallmarks of psuedoscience.

 

 

 

Mr Sorensen, you've just shown your true markings, as a Garliphobic nightwalker, masquerading as a cloaked day dwelling Vampiric Tree Officer.

 

Either that, or you've got an alternative up your sleeve

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

.

[Amelanchier]

Either that, or you've got an alternative up your sleeve

 

Nope, just caustic positivism.

 

• Why bring the product to market before long term peer reviewed trials?
   
  
• Why claim that because a product is 'natural', it harmless to the environment/people???
   
  
• If the product naturally occurs, how can you claim a patent?
   
  
• What are the long term effects of introducing a foreign compound into the tree in such quantities???
   
  
• Isn't it suspiciously fortunate that the treatment cures all the other maladies of HC??? Including 'Fungal disorders'???
   
  
• The Dutch regulator TNOs reports that form the backbone of the 'scientific' research only show P. syringae to be "inactivated" at the recommended concentrations. What happens when you stop the treatments...?
  

 

I could go on but I've got things to do with my life.

[Amelanchier]

I defer the last words to Hume.

 

"A wise man, therefore, proportions his belief to the evidence."

[Meep]

The product can't be sold until it has PSD approval

[scotspine1]

I couldn't be more sceptical about this. It has all the hallmarks of psuedoscience.

 

I agree Tony,

 

Did you hear about the homeopath who forgot to take his medicine?

.............he died of an overdose.

[skyhuck]

And there was that muppet who thought some mold could be of some medical use, what a fool, I think he was called Flemming.

[scotspine1]

And there was that muppet who thought some mold could be of some medical use, what a fool, I think he was called Flemming.

 

thats true, scientists are great, if they can make penicillin out of moldy bread maybe they can make something out of you

[Mesterh]

Saucer of milk for table 2.

[Amelanchier]

And there was that muppet who thought some mold could be of some medical use, what a fool, I think he was called Flemming.

 

Flemming could demonstrate the effectiveness of penicillin by repeatable falsifiable experiment.

 

Can the same thing be said of this product?

[skyhuck]

thats true, scientists are great, if they can make penicillin out of moldy bread maybe they can make something out of you

 

Euhh!!!! Handbags!!!!!!!!!!!

 

The point I was trying to make was that the most unexpected things can have untold promise.

 

Dr Flemming had the advantage of being able to use a petri dish, bit hard to get a mature HC into the lab.

 

I agree that there is a real chance this is a load of mumbo jumbo, BUT lets wait and see and hope for the best, I guess I'm just a glass half full kind of guy.

 

 

PS, top come back Tim you must be SO proud