Hi,
Hmm I did say to myself I would not get involved with a thread like this as it will bring up some many questions about the Management exercise. On the other hand it may be good to learn from each other’s mistakes but it’s very difficult to say what’s right or wrong on theses assessments as there very subjective. I feel if you explained your logic then this should give weight to your answers.
I felt the exercises where tough (but I suppose this is expected from tech cert) and the questions were broken down into more parts than I expected. This made allocating time a little easier but still there never felt like there was enough time.
Woodland exercise – I missed the badger set? but as important this is I would not say you would fail for missing this. I did express about conducting an ecological survey before work being carried out and find out on any designations on the woodland. This exercise was mainly about increasing biodiversity of the woodland with some small-scale timber production. This seemed ok to answer with my general answers being about improving native shrubs/hedge species, hazel coppice for timber, building a pond etc.
Plant ID – I felt this was as to be expected but did find I was repeating myself on some of the associated features. Good autumn colours etc
Tree Conditioning – Found this tricky as I always felt that I may have missed something but generally I felt the first few trees required the most amount of work. P+D was ok which was something like Fomes, Polyporous Sq, Grifola, Goat moth, Cherry canker?? I think the main thing for this assessment was to produce a report and draw up a schedule of work from your findings. I felt I may have specified to much work as they said budgets were tight but I did place a scale of urgency of work required on what I stated.
Tree in Environment – This for me was the hardest and where I know I made a good few mistakes. I did not have the right scale ruler (1:250) but produced a scale 1metre : 4mm I think? The marks for this where not as I expected with only 15 for the BS schedule which would mean about 17 minutes to spend on it. I took measurements for the two cedars and the redwood. Where I messed up was where I placed the barrier fencing, I left some areas where contractors could gain access into the RPA (not good!) and did not place it correctly around the development. I found the writtern questions unclear as what was expected. The method statement I wrote down as many different ways to prevent damage to the trees in a long list? The question before this I did not understand it entirely, I think it was about constraints so I mentioned a bit about RPA etc but felt I was not going in the right direction on this one.
So yeah a tough day and my head still hurts. I did hear there might be doing resits in the spring?
Good luck to you all and fair play to anyone who has passed the Prof Dip!!
Cheers Steve