Jump to content

Log in or register to remove this advert

Recommended Posts

Posted
Dear Kevin,

 

as I said in my original message, I've done wwoofing on and off. That means that in between, since being underage, till now (I'm 27), I've worked, even unpaid overtime, I've paid taxes, rented rooms and houses, paid bills, paid motorway tolls in France.. you name it. I've been a 'normal member of society'.

 

This conversation could get very deep, but I don't want to burden Doug's original thread. Let's just say that I'm one of those people who think the world would be a better place if we could opt where our taxes went. I'm sure no more than 10% of all I've ever paid in tax, has gone to street lamps, roads, and the NHS which by the way, yes I did rely on whilst wwoofing (except NHS - I like treating myself with plants.. very hippie of me I know... I just don't want pharma companies cashing in on all the money when a tonsillities can be cured with a thyme infusion...)

 

A safe bet would be however that most of it went to wars and feeding the army men, something I don't agree with. The day that changes, I might decide not to go off-grid.

 

In essence you could say that my working tax paid life has paid for the privilege for me to use the very few services that I used and still use.

 

As for society providing the platform for that chosen lifestyle, I think you're right, but I'd like to turn that statement into "it's BECAUSE of the state of society, that more and more people are looking to go off grid 'drop out' traveller lifestyles."

 

But I'm grateful. I love learning. It's why I'm doing wwoofing. I don't consider myself a dreamer. I consider myself someone reasonable, who's noticing that unemployment is constantly on the rise, that the divide between rich and poor is getting bigger, that families are being separated due to the pressures from their caring governments, that people don't know how to grow food or build their own homes anymore which humans have done most of their existance, that by the age I reach 'retirement', retirement age might not even exist, nor pensions for that matter, that old crafts are being lost, and that one day, we might need those skills when **** hits the fan. |

 

So what should one do? Pursue a career? Try not to get fired for the next 40 years of his/her life? Put half of it away in a savings account, hoping there's not another economic crisis when you'll discover the bankers once again stole all your money?

 

Meh.. I'd rather learn how to build my own home, grow my own veg, heal myself at home, ride a bicycle on dirt tracks to leave the shiny potholed roads to ever increasing fuel dependent cars, and spend less time working, and more time being with loved ones. Work to live, not live to work.

 

That romantic enough?

 

 

I was going to PM this so as not to further derail the thread, but I thought discussing the (perceived) pro's & cons may serve to raise awareness and potential engagement - wether that a) proves true or b) is nonsense, only time will tell.

 

 

It's difficult in a forum to communicate all the nuances of a conversation, seriously, when I said good on you and a part of me is envious, I meant just that. I take my hat off to you and I share many of the feelings / counter points you make above.

 

It wasn't meant as an "anti" or antagonistic post, but just as there are elements and sentiments I share with you, there are elements that I find contradictory and that make me a little uneasy.

 

Self sufficiency / self reliance / determination / resilience / responsibility etc etc.... All highly saleable / usable / necessary / diminishing skills. That's a massive plus.

 

The bit I struggle to reconcile is when some parts of the mainstream society are dropped but others are selectively retained. When this happens it tends to be the bits that are "useful" that are retained but without the necessary trappings of "collective contribution" - paying your contribution into the big pot.

 

I totally get when people are unhappy with the way some tax is spent - believe me, I'm one of them! But as individuals we divest that decision to the government. It ain't perfect, but what is?

 

So when woofing (or whatever other system of egalitarian lifestyle) purports to be an evolution of people power, it fundamentally fails to recognise that by not "paying in" the practitioner is by default taking a dump on someone further down the system that maybe reliant on the missing persons contribution into the big pot.

 

It's a dilemma, that's why part of me likes the concept, part of me doesn't.

Log in or register to remove this advert

  • Replies 53
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
Dear Kevin,

 

as I said in my original message, I've done wwoofing on and off. That means that in between, since being underage, till now (I'm 27), I've worked, even unpaid overtime, I've paid taxes, rented rooms and houses, paid bills, paid motorway tolls in France.. you name it. I've been a 'normal member of society'.

 

This conversation could get very deep, but I don't want to burden Doug's original thread. Let's just say that I'm one of those people who think the world would be a better place if we could opt where our taxes went. I'm sure no more than 10% of all I've ever paid in tax, has gone to street lamps, roads, and the NHS which by the way, yes I did rely on whilst wwoofing (except NHS - I like treating myself with plants.. very hippie of me I know... I just don't want pharma companies cashing in on all the money when a tonsillities can be cured with a thyme infusion...)

 

A safe bet would be however that most of it went to wars and feeding the army men, something I don't agree with. The day that changes, I might decide not to go off-grid.

 

In essence you could say that my working tax paid life has paid for the privilege for me to use the very few services that I used and still use.

 

As for society providing the platform for that chosen lifestyle, I think you're right, but I'd like to turn that statement into "it's BECAUSE of the state of society, that more and more people are looking to go off grid 'drop out' traveller lifestyles."

 

But I'm grateful. I love learning. It's why I'm doing wwoofing. I don't consider myself a dreamer. I consider myself someone reasonable, who's noticing that unemployment is constantly on the rise, that the divide between rich and poor is getting bigger, that families are being separated due to the pressures from their caring governments, that people don't know how to grow food or build their own homes anymore which humans have done most of their existance, that by the age I reach 'retirement', retirement age might not even exist, nor pensions for that matter, that old crafts are being lost, and that one day, we might need those skills when **** hits the fan. |

 

So what should one do? Pursue a career? Try not to get fired for the next 40 years of his/her life? Put half of it away in a savings account, hoping there's not another economic crisis when you'll discover the bankers once again stole all your money?

 

Meh.. I'd rather learn how to build my own home, grow my own veg, heal myself at home, ride a bicycle on dirt tracks to leave the shiny potholed roads to ever increasing fuel dependent cars, and spend less time working, and more time being with loved ones. Work to live, not live to work.

 

That romantic enough?

 

Well said and good luck to you. Ignore the naysayer's.

Posted
Ah I knew I shouldn't have mentioned that one.. especially as I no longer smoke...or drink... ah well. That one's on me.

 

Time travel? Hmm wouldn't want to.. back in the old days there were too many witch hunts.. and as for the future.. there'll probably be homeless hunts.

 

Heard of the 92yr old WW2 veteran who got arrested in Florida a few days ago for feeding the homeless?? Some new law about not being allowed to share food with people. Now that is why I love our governments. ;)

 

 

 

I was refering to the terminology not the act, I don't give a monkeys what people do as long as it doesn't have a negative affect on others.

Posted

Without volunteer opportunities like this its very difficult for young people to get a start in any sort of rural industry. I was able to get an apprenticeship in woodland management because I had gained experience through volunteering and doing unpaid work off my own back. Having done volunteer work also shows that you are dedicated. Now maybe its not the ideal situation and it would have been great if I could have just walked into a paid job but it just doesn't work like that anymore. Almost all employers want experienced staff. So if you can't get a job to gain that experience, where do you start. Most of my friends have gone down this route to get them the job they are in now. And this isn't just outdoor work but stuff in cities too where they have to pay rent and do an unpaid internship. Now thats really not a great situation, but its the nature of trying to find meaningful work these days. So to accuse these people of being tax dodgers seems a little unfair. You need to be able to get a job before you can pay tax.

Posted

Re original post if you fancy it then go for it, if not for you then don't comment and less of negativity re minimum wage and so forth.

 

Aic - how can you work for £170 a week, £35 a day in my arithmetic? (5 day week)

 

And you're out with your costs for running a car too!

Posted

This is no different to an internship, my son did a couple in London, he was paid £20 a day, cost him (me) £30 a day travelling, He,s now a fully employed graphic designer.

Posted

Hi Paul,

There is no minimum age - but they would have to be pretty keen & most likely personally known by any wwoofing hosts to take them on if under 18years old. Personally I would have to be very confident in taking anyone on under 20something.

Would def. be a good idea to suggest they check out helpx if volunteering is something they might like to do.

Thanks for following the thread - interesting developments. I thought the idea of volunteering in the woods might provoke some passion... but this thread was a surprise. All the best & I agree that volunteering can definitely be character building stuff.

Posted
This is no different to an internship, my son did a couple in London, he was paid £20 a day, cost him (me) £30 a day travelling, He,s now a fully employed graphic designer.

 

I was beaten to that magic word- 'internship'

Posted

Years ago I got fed up of my townie's life and decided to travel, see some new places, try different things. I ended up woofing in France. My discovery was rural life and outdoors work. On one farm I worked with Lourent from Quebec- lumberjack and man of many talents. That's the first time I got my hands on the chainsaw, later I spent rest of my time on the farm cutting firewood and felling my first trees. Second farm was owned by british family in Pyrenees, guy was a tree surgeon. Time there was spent climbing trees and learning knots etc.

I think this year of "work for bed and food" showed me what I wanted to do in my life. Now every day I load my pick up with toys and go to work thinking how fortunate I am to do what I enjoy.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  •  

About

Arbtalk.co.uk is a hub for the arboriculture industry in the UK.  
If you're just starting out and you need business, equipment, tech or training support you're in the right place.  If you've done it, made it, got a van load of oily t-shirts and have decided to give something back by sharing your knowledge or wisdom,  then you're welcome too.
If you would like to contribute to making this industry more effective and safe then welcome.
Just like a living tree, it'll always be a work in progress.
Please have a look around, sign up, share and contribute the best you have.

See you inside.

The Arbtalk Team

Follow us

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.