Meripilus on Oak...

[Steve Bullman]

Hate it when Tonys right...

 

 

when one has the patience of a saint, eventually all comes good.

 

Thats why i am confidant, I am just that good, that may suck for the rest but hey ho, not my problem! lmao:lol:

 

Bet you're really glad you posted that now Charles!

[swinny]

Bet you're really glad you posted that now Charles!

 

Lol if tony wants to lap it up thats fine by me!

 

The thread has had opinions etc and now a conclusion.

 

Without this the threads are useless, nothing but hot air and no outcome /learning

[Paul Cleaver]

and Oak is NOT a woodland tree, its natural home is the open structured pastureland

 

mmmmm are you sure mr MC hammer :

Edited November 30, 2013 by Paul Cleaver
improved Tonys name

[Charles Hey Arborist]

Bet you're really glad you posted that now Charles!

 

Wouldnt expect anything else from 'The Hama'

[jwade]

But can't oak make pure stands? And what about atlantic oak woodland - are these habitats not pre 1600 with 'ancient semi natural' characteristics?

[Paul Cleaver]

But can't oak make pure stands? And what about atlantic oak woodland - are these habitats not pre 1600 with 'ancient semi natural' characteristics?

 

[Tony Croft aka hamadryad]

and Oak is NOT a woodland tree, its natural home is the open structured pastureland

 

mmmmm are you sure mr MC hammer :

 

 

way too much evidence to prove it, both ways. you go find me regeneration in both habitats

[Tony Croft aka hamadryad]

Bet you're really glad you posted that now Charles!

 

 

I am just yanking chains, but you know that anyways, but i do smile when the inevitable happens and smug is as inevitable as being right!

 

tongue entirely in cheek, wouldnt be the same without the banter:001_smile:

[Tony Croft aka hamadryad]

But can't oak make pure stands? And what about atlantic oak woodland - are these habitats not pre 1600 with 'ancient semi natural' characteristics?

 

man has manipulated his environment for thousands of years.

 

The fact is those oak woodlands of which you speak, take wistmans wood dartmoor for instance, regen only occurs on the fringes, NOT within the wood itself.

 

Class dismissed:lol:

[Paul Cleaver]

way too much evidence to prove it, both ways. you go find me regeneration in both habitats

 

if left untouched in the right soil, Oak will establish naturally, a slow process mind.