Planting options post PR.

[Whoppa Choppa]

Hi All, recently we felled a decent volume of PR infected Sweet Chestnut on some of my land.

 

We've thrashed out a replanting list and want rapid establishment and have decided on a broadleaf mix with conifer nurse, pref. DF. We're going for Nothofagus (S.Beech) as it suits the area, geography, etc. Only concern is that both these are listed as "plant with caution" under FC guidance - see attached pdf. Any thoughts? Many thanks.advice_on_replanting_sites_felled_due_to_phytophthora_2017 (003) - Common names added - complete.pdf

Edited August 30 by Whoppa Choppa

[AHPP]

Whatever the government says, do the opposite. 
 

I thought you weren’t bothering with us retards on here btw?

Edited August 30 by AHPP

[Whoppa Choppa]

9 hours ago, AHPP said:

Whatever the government says, do the opposite. 
 

I thought you weren’t bothering with us retards on here btw?

When did I say that?!

[AHPP]

About your fifth post. 

[Whoppa Choppa]

10 hours ago, AHPP said:

About your fifth post. 

 

You're better than me.

[Whoppa Choppa]

Useful derail there - not. 

 

Do I abandon this thread or hope there might be some interest or advice?

[5thelement]

On 30/08/2024 at 13:17, Whoppa Choppa said:

Hi All, recently we felled a decent volume of PR infected Sweet Chestnut on some of my land.

 

We've thrashed out a replanting list and want rapid establishment and have decided on a broadleaf mix with conifer nurse, pref. DF. We're going for Nothofagus (S.Beech) as it suits the area, geography, etc. Only concern is that both these are listed as "plant with caution" under FC guidance - see attached pdf. Any thoughts? Many thanks.advice_on_replanting_sites_felled_due_to_phytophthora_2017 (003) - Common names added - complete.pdf

I have previously had to clear fell a mixed block of Larch and Southern Beech, planted in the 70’s in East Sussex, due to PR. 
The Southern beech was looking fantastic at the time. 
Where is your location and any idea on soil type?

I certainly wouldn’t be planting two tree types that are commonly known to be susceptible to PR. 

[Whoppa Choppa]

Seems us and the planting contractor have both had senior moments here. The site is very hot with PR so how on earth did we arrive at DF and S.beech 🤯.

[Whoppa Choppa]

2 minutes ago, Whoppa Choppa said:

Seems us and the planting contractor have both had senior moments here. The site is very hot with PR so how on earth did we arrive at DF and S.beech 🤯.

 

And thinking about it, how did the FC plant health bloke miss this?! 

[Donnie]

11 hours ago, Whoppa Choppa said:

Useful derail there - not. 

This made me laugh… 

What’s everyone had for tea tonight?