Discovery apple tree

[Moira Mount]

Hi I have a discovery apple tree in a large pot, it's my first year for fruiting. This apple is supposedly ready mid August but it was late September when I picked the few it had on due to them not coming off the tree easily in August. They were quite tarty and had a green tinge as I peeled them. Could this be due to its first year of fruiting. I fed it seaweed feed during the growing season. 

Edited October 9 by Moira Mount

[Squaredy]

1 hour ago, Moira Mount said:

Hi I have a discovery apple tree in a large pot, it's my first year for fruiting. This apple is supposedly ready mid August but it was late September when I picked the few it had on due to them not coming off the tree easily in August. They were quite tarty and had a green tinge as I peeled them. Could this be due to its first year of fruiting. I fed it seaweed feed during the growing season. 

Doesn't really sound like Discovery to me.  Have you photos of the apples?

[peds]

When you say green tinge, is this as well as the pinkish flesh you'd hope to see in a Discovery... or instead of?

 

Could you show us a photo of the graft, as if there's no display of pink at all the graft could quite well have failed, and you are just growing the rootstock fruit instead...

[Muddy42]

Doesn't sound right. Discovery is always the first edible apple of the year, even when young and delicious.

[Moira Mount]

Hi, no they didn't have the pinky flesh. My biggest weighed over half a pound and they are supposed to be a smallish apple. I was wondering if it's like this with it being it's first fruiting year.

[Moira Mount]

This photo was taken before August this year. They were really red when they came off the tree.

[Moira Mount]

[peds]

Hm, they don't really look right do they. Where did you buy it?

 

I'd say the tree was mislabelled. 

[Peasgood]

Not sure what they are, maybe a red sport of James Grieve from the appearance and description but only a guess.

They are definitely not Discovery.