This is great, seems like we are having a proper debate. Perhaps the best place to start to look for evidence about Glyphosate and trees would be the vast areas of forest in South America that the CIA regularly sprayed by plane in the seventies and eighties to try and eradicate the coca plantations. This was a handy little trial for Monsanto to test their product because at the same time GM crop trials were also going on in the area and the resilience of these crops could be monitored. As has been said before research is one thing but to actually get funding to carry out the research is something completely different again and I suspect just would not happen in the English speaking world. Let's say funding had been secured and research carried out then who would publish the results? I can't see anyone other than a competitor with a new competitive product having the means to get the data out in the public domain. Like I said before if anybody feels that strongly about this issue then the place to look is Scandanavia where I am sure Glyphosate is banned in the public and amenity sectors. The research would certainly be there if anyone could translate it as I am sure certain countries in South America would also have done extensive research. Let's not forget that it is Monsanto we are talking about and Glyphosate for them is just an unimaginable cash cow. Prices go up and down willy nilly according to the time of year. Farmers are drilling winter wheat or rape after harvest just so come Spring they can go out, spray it off and stick the bill in for another ridiculous subsidy.
BASIS are just a bunch of old boys, sales, contractors, research? and a token Minister. They just had a meeting in Brussels no doubt very expensive, this meeting lasted a maximum of twenty minutes. The newly appointed head of BASIS Lord someone or other introduced himself said thanks for picking him, it seems like an interesting area to be "working" in lets push the industry forward and create new and exciting opportunities for the future, thanks for coming goodbye.
I know we are going off thread with this but it is an important subject and I believe that just because we are brainwashed into believing it's good doesn't mean to say it is. Would we have sprayed our Dogs or Children with DDT in the sixties for fleas? I think the answer is YES we would and we bloody well did! Is Microsoft Windows a good operating system? NO it is not, so how come Bill Gates has taken over the world?
Did Professor Diesel develop his engine to run on a dirty filthy waste product from the petro-chemical industry, NO he did not, it was developed to run on vegetable oil, funny how he just disappeared one day never to be seen again.
We all have our interests to protect and Glyphosate fills the vegetation control niche nicely. It is however hand in hand with GM crops(that's the big picture and who of us would really want to have these monstrous creations in our back yard?). Monsanto will protect their own interests with there own research and blackmail funding to "independent" agencies. We have our own interests to protect and that is why Glyphosate is so widely used, but lets not lose sight of the fact that we have come from the earth and will go back to the earth and we have not inherited it from our ancestors but borrowed it from our children.
Oh my word I'm rambling now, Glyphosate is a salt that is held in liquid suspension. This liquid is as far as I know mostly water, but there are additives such as an adjuvant to help the product stick to its target and other things I can't remember, so although we are talking Glyphosate the actual product the consumer uses is not actually just Glyphosate. I wonder if research reflects this?
While I'm at it someone coming on here claiming that in "another life" they worked in development of pesticides in the Agrochemical industry" and if you're not in the BASIS club watch what you say because you could be prosecuted blah, blah, blah....... Well I really don't want to come across as demeaning in any way but was your spelling that bad when you were copying down formulas???? Could you not be bothered to use a spell check????? I personally find that highly insulting. Just about sums up the state of corporate Britain plc.
Anyway people peace on earth and remember 95% of statistics are made up, or was it 75%? or is it 33% of statistics are not made up... can't remember.......
A Happy, Healthy and Prosperous New Year to all..