Harkie Defiance smock

[Treetom15]

Anyone got one or had good/bad experience with them? 
 

I had their innovation 2 smock, great for awful weather but terrible for climbing, just wondered how people rate the defiance as they look like quite a good fit for climbing? 

[ABtrees]

3 hours ago, Treetom15 said:

Anyone got one or had good/bad experience with them? 
 

I had their innovation 2 smock, great for awful weather but terrible for climbing, just wondered how people rate the defiance as they look like quite a good fit for climbing? 

 

Hi Tom

I thought I'd seen this topic before.  If you put Harkie Defiance in the search box, there already quite a bit of opinion on them on here.

Not having a go - just trying to help !

AB

[Treetom15]

@ABtrees thanks, will have a look

EDIT-the other posts on here are related to the older smock (innovation 2) this is for the newer defiance model. 

Edited April 23 by Treetom15

[jameshs22]

Also interested in peoples opinions on this jacket. Thinking of getting one as well 

[krummholz]

The Defiance doesn't look dissimilar to the Innovation in terms of length, which is what I found annoying about it for climbing in.

 

I used to wear old goretex jackets as they were fairly hard wearing for tree climbing but the zips would always go, Musto do a goretex smock that might be alright?

MUSTO Ravine Gore-tex Smock

INTHESPORT.CO

---

The Musto Ravine Gore-Tex Smock is a waterproof and breathable jacket designed for outdoor activities such as skiing and...

 

Petition to bring back the Cut and Climb - I wonder if there was a crowd funder and enough folk signed up whether they'd do another run of them?

[Treetom15]

6 hours ago, krummholz said:

Petition to bring back the Cut and Climb - I wonder if there was a crowd funder and enough folk signed up whether they'd do another run of them?

I tried a cut & climb jacket on a training course ages ago, spent the whole day in it and by far the best I’ve tried for climbing in. Someone must have the rights/pattern to it somewhere?