-
Posts
57 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Classifieds
Tip Site Directory
Blogs
Articles
News
Arborist Reviews
Arbtalk Knot Guide
Gallery
Store
Calendar
Freelancers directory
Posts posted by Stu33J
-
-
28 minutes ago, Treewolf said:
Don't believe all you read on the Internet, for a much more honest discussion read the whole thread on here. See ' 200 year old cedar in Dorset' in the general chat forum
https://arbtalk.co.uk/forums/topic/64358-200year-old-cedar-in-dorset/#comments
"
The tree had been tested by myself last year with the Picus tomograph and was shown to have significant decay present due to colonisation by Phaeolus.
This year both Mick Boddy and myself spent most of a day testing with the Tomograph and two resistographs just to be sure of the accuracy of our results.
We tested at several heights and found extensive levels of advanced tissue degradation.
The National trust considered all of the evidence and also asked Jeremy Barrell for an opinion.
Be it financial or H&S they took a decision to fell the tree.
We can all stand back and pass comment and be critical about anothers decision but the National Trust will have to carry the can in the event of a claim. I would like to have seen the tree kept following a reduction but I can understand the N T stance. We live in a world where litigation can influnece many decisions."
- 6
- 3
-
4 minutes ago, Treewolf said:
Worth remembering that the Nat Trust, which is quite rightly up in arms, is the organisation that felled the Wellington Cedar at Kingston Lacy only a few years ago.
Hypocrisy or a new enlightenment?
"The cedar tree, which was planted on the Kingston Lacy estate in Dorset in 1827, will be pulled down because it is rotten."
"The National Trust said the 'landmark' tree had to be felled immediately after experts found there was only five per cent live wood left in the trunk."
That's what I found on internet
- 1
-
5 minutes ago, dan blocker said:
What’s it to do with the Arb Association? Bit like a Motorcycle Club getting together with the police on Traffic laws, or the National Trust come to think of it - they can’t even manage their own trees and woodlands correctly?
Hello Dan
Well the police would provide the legal aspect of the criminal damage that's been done. The Arb Association could then help promote good pruning practices and the National Trust, being the largest private land owner in the UK could help influence more robust legislation to help protect other trees and help prevent something like this happening again in the future. Being a member of both the Arb Association and NTS I've seen the positive impact they can have.
You say they can't manage their own trees and woodlands correctly. Perhaps you could assist?
-
17 minutes ago, MattyF said:
No they just felled it in storm winds, we had storm Abigail last night and a full moon, it was only going in one direction.. this was planned for such a night.
Sycamore Gap: Boy, 16, arrested after Hadrian's Wall tree felled
WWW.BBC.CO.UK
The Sycamore Gap tree was cut down overnight in what police believe was an act of vandalism. -
This would be a good time, while this situation is being highlighted by the media for the likes of the Arboricultural Association, National Trust & NTS, etc., to band together alongside the Police to not only ensure the maximum fine is applied but to also highlight the importance of trees like this and the reasons as to why they are protected and that all trees should be pruned, if actually required, correctly and to the proper standards.
- 2
-
5 minutes ago, Doug Tait said:
He might be young but he knows how to use it
Exactly! It looks like this boy has clearly had training and if so then he should have known better
- 1
-
6 minutes ago, Bob_z_l said:
Worse. A minor. Essentially immune from prosecution.
I wonder what drove him that far to want to do something like that. Must be quite disturbed/angry about something.£20k fine as that tree must have been protected.
- 1
-
Just heard on LBC that police have arrested a 16yo boy in connection to the felling of the tree.
- 2
-
Bloke on here just had 560 blow up, see if he wants it [emoji6] k
I’d already sold it to a friend. I just needed to confirm an honest and fair price for a second hand saw and the prices suggested were as expected.- 1
-
Depends on what the saw looks like....I have seen "light use" look like it has been dragged out of a village pond before. If it looks nice, £250 is probably a bit light and would think £250-£320 if the plastics, bottom and stickers are nice and it has a lightly used bar, chain and scabbard.
eBay sales generate good prices but you can get done over by ebays lack of love of trusted traders!!
Light scuff marks on bottom and sprocket side from sticking it on the ground to move stuff and to refuel, has a sugihara bar, semi chisel chain half worn and an older scabbard from a 346xp as the 550’s was left on a job. Stickers all as they should be.
Sold to a friend and wanted to make sure we each got a fair price plus we regularly work on jobs together. -
Thanks for your input, much appreciated folks. [emoji106]
- 1
-
Hello
Out of interest how much do you guys think a 550xpg mk 1 with occasional use be worth these days?
Everything works as it should and runs perfectly.
-
Is that a picus your are wanting done? Roughly whereabouts are you? As I know a couple of guys in fife.
Yeah a picus. NE Aberdeenshire. -
Unfortunately its only one tree needing done so I guess that’s not worth your while?
-
Hi All,
Looking for some assistance please. I'm looking for a Decay Detection Survey in NE Scotland. Is there anyone in the area that could help?
-
Yeah I know a LOLER Inspector if you're still looking for one?
-
-
Thats some interesting information to think about, thanks guys.
I’m probably going to look into older machines and see whats available by checking out the various links on the website.
Yes I am fairly mechanically minded and I don’t need to worry about towing weight restrictions. -
Hello everyone.
I’m looking for advice on buying a chipper and I’m wondering if I should buy new (unfortunately on finance) or look at 2nd hand? I’ve used a number of chippers over the years and they all have their strengths and weaknesses.
If anyone knows of something decent for a reasonable price I could be interested to know about that.
Tracked machines would be great but of course they are more expensive so it would depend on the price.
If any dealers have something that could suit me I would be interested to hear from you.
-
What about New England Braided Safety Blue? That’s what I’m currently climbing on. ZZ no good on that?
-
Hi everyone. Looking for people’s opinions on whats the best rope to use on the new ZigZag Plus?
-
-
Could sell you a 550xpg and I've just sold a 346xp along with an extra crankcase. Could speak to the guy and see what his plans are for the 346
-
Hello all.
Has anyone used Polexim chippers before or does anyone own one? Would be interested to hear about people's opinions and experiences from those that have used them.
WOW
in General chat
Posted
Ha ha, funny as!
Triangulation is a good thing!