Seeking feedback on tree placement & aesthetics

[m kos]

Hi, I am looking for feedback on tree placement that will frame my house while providing shade and screen. For starters, I’m thinking about removing the two exterior Pine trees, keeping the one in the center. Second, I was considering the addition of a dwarf Japanese Maple on the South side about 15’ from South Corner of the house. Finally, adding an Oak Regal Prince on the North side about 15’ from the North Corner OR pleached Hornbeams along the North property line. I’ve attached 3 current pictures as well as a proposed picture that I created using landscaping software. I wasn’t able to include the view of the Pine tree, but it provides a little idea of the new tree placement. Any feedback or advice on the tree placement, types of trees, etc. would be greatly appreciated. FYI - I live in zone 5-6 and the front of my home faces West; dimensions: 36' from house to line of Pine trees. 60' property width (left property line to house 10', front of house 21', house to right property line 29') Thank you, Marc

[Steve Bullman]

Hi Marc, this is a UK based forum but you will still get the advice you need, but can you clarify for us what zone 5-6 means please?

[m kos]

Hi Steve, I live outside Chicago our USDA plant hardiness "zone" is 5-6, so -28.9 degrees C is the minimum temperature plants will thrive in. Thanks, Marc

[Midge]

What is wrong with the pines? It looks as if the outer two aren't growing as well as the middle one is that why you want rid of them?

[m kos]

I like the Pines too except for the bare spots, so that is why I was considering removing them. I also feel like something is missing, so that is why I was looking at planting something closer to the house.

[fagus]

Hi Marc, I am fortunate to have spent quite a bit of time in the US.The idea seems fine to me. I prefer the Oak to Hornbeams although the Oak at 15 foot might be a bit close- depends on how good your foundations are i.e size and construction,soil type. At that distance it would certainly overshadow the property at some point.Though I note the lawn slopes away from the house so the Oak position is not critical.

However it is not so easy for UK based people to comprehend planting trees to give property shade and avoid excessive heat which might be what you seek long term.

[m kos]

Hi Fagus, thanks for your feedback. We removed a huge Oak tree from the middle of the yard about 4 years ago. It was hanging over the roof and some of the main branches were thought to be unhealthy. So, I share your concerns about the foundation and the potential overshadowing. The first floor is our garage and the second floor is part of our master suite and we really feel the summer heat now that we've removed the Oak. So, you are right we are hoping to add a little heat relief. I guess I should look more at dwarf varieties of trees for the space. Thanks again for your response.

[iwoo]

What do other folks along your street have planted to provide shade? it might give you an idea of what suits your needs.