Quantifying risks from many trees

[Blakes 7]

Shabz statistics:

 

the chance of you winning the lottery with one ticket is around 14 million to one, what would 7 mean to someone?

Chance of failure of tree causing injury 10000 to 1, or 2???

[arb culture]

Just give me a worked example and let me show you what I mean.

[arb culture]

Oh, and just in case anyone thinks I don't know what I'm talking about; I have read all the literature which is usually quoted, know a lot of people who have done the training, and have seen several copies of the the literature bundle given to people who go on the training.

 

I have also seen many many QTRA reports, but I won't comment on them without the author's express permission. That would just be rude, even if they are in the public domain.

 

Honestly, I promise you, I'm not new to this.

[Albedo]

so whats yer point mate

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

.

Edited March 11, 2010 by Monkey-D
language

[Albedo]

Cheers for the edit monkeyd (of my swear word). I've just re read the whole thread properly and I see what arb culture's trying to get at, just found it a bit obtuse.

 

As I'm not really contributing to this one you can delete both these posts if you like.

 

I thought I'd be in trouble for that one:biggrin:

[arb culture]

Is anyone prepared to give us a worked example of a QTRA for discussion?

[Bundle 2]

Oh, and just in case anyone thinks I don't know what I'm talking about; I have read all the literature which is usually quoted, know a lot of people who have done the training, and have seen several copies of the the literature bundle given to people who go on the training.

 

I have also seen many many QTRA reports, but I won't comment on them without the author's express permission. That would just be rude, even if they are in the public domain.

 

Honestly, I promise you, I'm not new to this.

 

And you remain unconvinced. You go on about it as if it is up to someone other than yourself to work out which way is up....! GO DO THE TRAINING.

[arb culture]

What do you have to hide?

 

Just show us a worked example - why is that so bloomin hard?

[stevelucocq]

hi do not mean to side track this. I attend the QTRA course last year and have used it a little since. I am trying to get up to speed with my QTRA experience and I am looking for a few examples for me to think about and work through. Anyone got a few for me? Thanks Steve

[Bundle 2]

hi do not mean to side track this. I attend the QTRA course last year and have used it a little since. I am trying to get up to speed with my QTRA experience and I am looking for a few examples for me to think about and work through. Anyone got a few for me? Thanks Steve

 

If you are not already a subscibed member of the QTRA forum, ( this is likely the case as a licensed user ) then I would suggest perhaps you could change your preferences to receive mail as it is generated. There are a number of examples that appear in real time aswell as some discussion around related issues of risk assessment and in particular, the way QTRA is used and thought about by those trained in it's use. But then you knew that didnt you?